Friday, June 19, 2026 Advertise Contact Subscribe
Food & Drink

Savor the Flavors of Fire Island: Top 5 Restaurants for an Unforgettable Dining Experience

Treat yourself to the top restaurants in Fire Island and indulge in a variety of delicious dishes at Hideaway Restaurant, Island Mermaid, Albatross, Sand Castle, and The Landing at Ocean

by Long Island Wave April 4, 2023 Food & Drink

Fire Island, a picturesque island off the coast of Long Island, offers not only stunning beaches and breathtaking views, but also a vibrant culinary scene. From casual beachside eateries to elegant dining experiences, there's something for everyone.

We've curated a list of the top 5 restaurants in Fire Island that you won't want to miss.

Hideaway Restaurant

Located in Ocean Bay Park, Hideaway Restaurant offers a laid-back atmosphere with a diverse menu that features something for everyone. Enjoy their delicious seafood dishes, such as the clam bake or the fish tacos, while taking in the beautiful waterfront views. The casual ambiance and friendly service make Hideaway Restaurant a perfect spot to unwind after a day at the beach.

Learn More

Directions

Island Mermaid

Island Mermaid, situated in the heart of Ocean Beach, is a popular dining destination that offers an array of delectable dishes with an emphasis on fresh seafood. From their famous lobster roll to their savory shrimp and grits, there's something for every palate. The welcoming atmosphere and waterfront dining make Island Mermaid a must-visit spot on Fire Island.

Learn More

Directions

Albatross

Nestled in Cherry Grove, Albatross is a cozy, intimate restaurant known for its delicious menu and charming atmosphere. Featuring a variety of dishes, such as wood-fired pizzas, fresh seafood, and seasonal salads, Albatross is perfect for a relaxed dinner with friends or a romantic evening. Be sure to try one of their signature cocktails to complete your dining experience.

Learn More

Directions

Sand Castle

Located in Ocean Beach, Sand Castle offers a casual dining experience with a focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. With its laid-back vibe and mouthwatering menu, Sand Castle is a great choice for a casual meal with family or friends. Don't miss their signature seafood dishes, such as the crab cakes and the fisherman's platter.

Learn More

Directions

The Landing at Ocean Beach

The Landing at Ocean Beach is a contemporary American restaurant that offers a sophisticated dining experience with stunning waterfront views. Their menu features an array of dishes, including seafood, steaks, and pasta, all prepared with fresh, seasonal ingredients. The elegant setting and attentive service make The Landing at Ocean Beach the perfect destination for a special night out.

Learn More

Directions

Fire Island boasts a diverse culinary landscape that ranges from casual beachside eateries to upscale dining establishments. Whether you're craving fresh seafood or a delicious wood-fired pizza, these top 5 restaurants in Fire Island are sure to satisfy your taste buds and make your visit unforgettable.

← All Long Island Wave news
The Weekly Wave

The best of Long Island, in your inbox every Friday.

New openings, the events worth your weekend, and the people and places shaping how Long Island lives. One email, no noise.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. By Wave Agency.